HONG KONG — The city’s legislative elections on Sunday generated an unexpected secondary market as official thank-you cards distributed to voters immediately appeared for resale online, fetching prices ranging from HK$10 to HK$80. Following the conclusion of the polls, which saw citizens receive the commemorative cards touted by the government, several posts surfaced on popular online platforms, including Carousell, advertising the unique tokens, potentially driven by exclusive commercial discounts tied to the cards.
The controversial trading began even before polls officially opened. On Saturday, solicitations for the cards were already active on secondhand sites, with some users offering up to HK$40 per card. By Sunday morning, shortly after voting commenced, multiple sellers began listing the physical cards for immediate sale. One seller justified the price by emphasizing the cards’ quality, noting the “beautiful design, suitable for collection or as a souvenir,” and highlighting their vibrant colors and display of Hong Kong’s cityscape, adding that such opportunities arise only “once every four years.”
The Appeal of Commercial Perks
The unexpected demand for the tokens appears directly related to a coordinated effort by local businesses to incentivize participation. Numerous retailers, restaurant chains, and entertainment venues announced special promotions exclusively for citizens presenting the official thank-you card.
A major draw was the discount offered by the cinema industry. A collective of ten major theater chains announced that cardholders could purchase one half-price movie ticket on Sunday, excluding special screenings or private events. Participating chains included Broadway Circuit, MCL Cinema, Emperor Cinemas, and Golden Harvest. Beyond entertainment, various restaurants and retailers offered holders perks such as 10% discounts on meals or complimentary “buy-one-get-one-free” coffee promotions.
“While the discounts themselves are generally minor, the sheer volume of businesses participating, from cinemas to coffee shops, made the cards attractive in aggregate,” explained Dr. Chan Wai-man, a consumer behavior analyst based in Hong Kong. “For some who may not have voted but desired the discounts, or for speculators aiming to profit from the combined value of the perks, this created a low-level gray market immediately following the civic event.”
Online Platform Scrutiny
The immediate resale of the government-issued tokens raises questions about the ethics versus the legality of trading symbolic, non-transferable civic incentives. While the cards themselves bear no face value, trading them for monetary gain potentially subverts the government’s intent to reward democratic participation.
Online platforms have a checkered history of managing the resale of subsidized or government-linked items. Sources within Carousell did not immediately comment on whether they intend to regulate or remove the listings specifically tied to the election cards.
While the discounts remain available only to cardholders, the transfer of the physical card, sometimes sold in bulk by single users, suggests some level of arbitrage is occurring, with individuals treating the commemorative item as a commodity tied to temporary commercial value. The situation highlights the challenges of linking civic participation to tangible, transferable economic incentives and managing the subsequent response in the digital resale economy. As the window for most discounts expires soon, observers expect the resale activity to dissipate quickly.
Leave a Reply