A thorough investigation by Hong Kong’s Consumer Council has rattled the kitchen appliance market, revealing that high-price induction cooktops aren’t necessarily a safe bet. Testing 13 dual-zone and full-surface models from well-known brands, the report uncovered severe heating failures, widespread low-heat inefficiency, and deceptive energy labels that could compromise both cooking results and household safety.
The Price of Convenience Is Not Always Right
Induction hobs have become the go-to choice for modern home cooks thanks to their sleek surfaces, ease of cleaning, and ability to keep kitchens cool. However, the Council’s test—published in Choice Issue 568—found that prices ranging from HK$3,680 to over HK$21,000 offered no guarantee of performance. During a standard oil-heating test, two models failed spectacularly: the German Pool GIC-252DB and the Giggas GS-238D could not heat cooking oil to the required 180°C within 45 minutes. A third unit, the Panasonic KY-C223B, was also sluggish, taking nearly 40 minutes to reach target temperatures. In contrast, the ten better-performing models completed the task in just 13 to 25 minutes.
Nearly 70% of Models Fail the Simmer Test
Low-heat control is crucial for Hong Kong cuisine, which frequently relies on slow braising and gentle soups. Unfortunately, almost 70% of the tested units failed to meet international standard IEC 60350-2 for low-power performance. In a specialized chocolate-melting test, most models raised temperatures too quickly, bypassing the fine control required for delicate simmering. Only four units properly maintained the strict temperature curves needed for gentle cooking.
Heat Distribution and Energy Vampires Emerge as Key Concerns
Uneven heating affected five of the tested samples, creating distinct hot spots that led to unevenly cooked food. The newer full-surface models fared particularly poorly: the zone between the two cooking coils showed significantly weaker heat, meaning long pans would cook unevenly from end to end. The German Pool unit even triggered a safety shut-off due to overheating during the heat distribution test.
On energy efficiency, the Rasonic RIC-S44E offered a striking contradiction. While it was the fastest to heat oil in the test, its standby power consumption exceeded two watts, placing it at an actual efficiency rating of Grade 5 rather than the Grade 2 listed on its label. The Council identified five other samples whose real energy performance was one grade lower than advertised, and has forwarded the evidence to the Electrical and Mechanical Services Department (EMSD) for follow-up.
Safety Advice for Induction Cooktop Users
To reduce the risk of fire or electrical failure, the Council recommends the following measures:
- Use a dedicated power socket. Induction hobs draw high wattage; sharing an outlet with other heavy appliances can overload circuits.
- Choose the right cookware. Only use flat-bottomed pans specifically designed for induction to ensure proper heat transfer and avoid damaging the ceramic surface.
- Inspect the glass top before cooking. A cracked or chipped surface can expose the induction coil and pose an electric shock or fire hazard.
- Let the fan do its job. Never cut power immediately after use. The internal cooling fan needs to run to protect sensitive electronics and extend the unit’s lifespan.
The Bottom Line
This report serves as a critical reminder that brand reputation and price point cannot replace independent testing. Consumers looking to upgrade their kitchen should consult the full Choice Issue 568 results before making a decision. With fire risks, simmering failures, and mismarked labels in play, an informed purchase isn’t just about better cooking—it’s about household safety.